Redesigning an Inefficient Document Management System
Project Overview
This case study focuses on redesigning the system to improve efficiency and usability, especially for older employees who struggle with technology and find the interface cumbersome.
Background
Phoenix Key Systems, a leading insurance company, manages a large volume of documents from policyholders and agents. These documents include important details like social security numbers, policy information, and financial data, all essential for the company’s operations.
The Problem
The users faced multiple challenges that hindered the system’s usability and employee efficiency:
❌ extensive manual input is necessitated by users because of unreliable automated data entry.
❌ Inefficiencies in workflow led to frequent screen and menu switching, causing delays in processes.
❌ The user interface was not user-friendly, posing challenges for elderly and less tech-savvy employees like Complicated navigation and unnecessary scrolling.
❌ Lack of feedbackon why certain data couldn't be entered automatically caused confusion among users.
The Solution
✅ Improved User Interface: Simplified navigation with an intuitive, user-friendly design.
✅ Efficient Workflow: Minimized manual data entry to reduce errors and improve efficiency.
✅ Real-time Feedback: Immediate alerts on validation or low-quality data help users understand entry issues.
✅ Enhanced Accessibility: The design improves legibility, hierarchy, contrast, and consistency to meet the needs of elderly employees, ensuring comfortable interaction with the system.
✅ Streamlined Reports: Redesigned the reporting interface for better visual appeal and easier data interpretation.
User Research
The research assessed the system’s automation reliability, user interface intuitiveness, and clarity of feedback for users, especially the elderly.
Findings and Conclusions
👨💻 Reliability of Automation:
A significant number of users reported issues with the automated data entry, often resorting to manual input.
👷♀️ Workflow Efficiency:
Users frequently had to switch between screens, leading to delays and a disrupted workflow.
👨🏻🦳 User Interface Evaluation:
The interface was found to be particularly challenging for elderly users, indicating a need for a more intuitive design.
🤔 Feedback Clarity:
Users were often left confused due to the lack of clear feedback on data entry issues. This highlighted the need for more transparent error messages and guidance.
User Study and Personas
My research delved into the system’s automation reliability, user interface intuitiveness, and the clarity of feedback. We aimed to understand the user experience and identify areas for improvement.
Personas
Sarah
Senior employee
Sarah struggles with complex interfaces and technological changes. The new system includes a clear notification area for immediate error feedback and the ability to collapse sections, reducing visual clutter and improving navigation.
Alex
Mid-level employee
Alex focuses on efficiency but is slowed down by manual data entry and cumbersome workflows. The updated system provides real-time validation for error correction and allows direct field marking, streamlining his workflow and preventing delays.
Wireframes
After my research it was necessary to change the “skeleton” of the system so that everything is open and visible, thus enabling a faster and more convenient transition between areas in the work environment.
🧭 Unified Navigation Design
Position the main menu at the top with a secondary side menu, ensuring clear hierarchy and seamless transitions between areas.
🧠 Simplified Navigation
Drop-down subtitles make information easily accessible, reducing scrolling and cognitive strain.
🔔 Notifications
Receive alerts within the dropdowns, so you only open what needs attention—enhancing efficiency and engagement.
🚀 Streamlined Problem Solving
We've created a dedicated space for unrecognized fields, making it effortless for employees to tackle system recognition issues in one place.
📌 Marking & Tips
We highlight ID problems on documents and offer helpful tips right on empty fields for easy issue resolution.
Final Design
Taking into consideration the main topics that came up in my research, I aimed to create a clean and very clear design with a bright, and contrast colors. So that they attract the attention of the users and highlight the problems